Login Form  

Top Stories  

Network With Us  

Quotation  

"Liberty is to the collective body, what health is to every individual body.  Without health no pleasure can be tasted by man; without liberty, no happiness can be enjoyed by society."

— Henry St. John

 

Install The Health Wyze Report browser search plug-in. Also, check out our new Firefox browser persona, which is easy on the eyes, and emphasizes the natural beauty of polished copper.

Are you in need of help with your addiction but have no where to turn? There are drug rehab programs that can help you get on the right path to recovery.

Byte Back! is a chamomile-based, natural remedy for insect bites and itchy skin irritation. We can vouch for it because we make it ourselves. Read more about it, or visit our store

William Kay, M.D., is a Health Wyze Report partner and a fellow health detective.

Get some goodies and support our work at the same time.

Learn about it or order it. There is nothing else like this for skin and joint problems.

Utopia Silver Supplements
This is the best colloidal silver that the H.W. staff has ever used. If you call, tell Ben Taylor that we sent you.

The Cancer Report is the must see documentary from The Health Wyze Report. Watch it now! The DVD is available in our store.

Alternative Medicine Fraud: Magnet Therapy

Written by Thomas Corriher Saturday, 29 May 2010 20:21
PrintE-mail

Magnets are becoming popularized as a method for treating swelling and joint issues, with magnetic therapy growing to a billion dollar business internationally.  This is due to massive marketing schemes which are extremely deceptive.  Magnet therapy advertisements plague the June issue of Carolina Country, a free magazine that is distributed by Energy United, a power utilities company.  Pictured right is an entry-level magnet product that was featured, which allegedly relieves stiffness and fatigue.  It is made from spandex and has embedded magnets.  The manufacturer sells a large line of magnet-based "therapies".  They hook their victims using products like this one.  This particular entry-level product is one of the cheaper ones that is designed to reel-in gullible people for future sales.  (Only $9.97!)

Here is how the scam works.  Customers are beguiled by the fact that the magnets will appear to help, due to the tight and warm spandex wrapping; not the magnets themselves.  Attaching a tight spandex bandaging to a swelled area will concentrate healing warmth, and its pressure will help to reduce swelling.  This has absolutely nothing to do with magnets, and any sports coach can easily explain it.

It is important to note that the real agenda behind this particular product is simply to introduce the victims to believable "magnet therapy", so that they will eventually be purchasing magnetic bed covers too (above $100), magnetic jewelry, and even magnetic slippers.  After all, a tight and warm bandage that helps to relieve a sore knee is obviously indisputable proof that magnetic radiation is beneficial to health.  At least, that's the bogus connection that we're supposed to make.

Vendors take advantage of the fact that most people have no idea how magnets work.  Thus, they can make claims which have no basis in reality.  Here is an example from one of the magnet marketing web sites:

"Magnetic fields attract calcium ions in the blood, which then press against blood-vessel walls for a dilating effect that optimizes circulation.  This improves oxygenation of injured tissue to promote healing."

Magnets have no effect on calcium whatsoever, but the truth is not a very good selling point.  Magnets only act upon iron, and compounds containing iron.  The truth is that studies have repeatedly shown that magnet therapy has no greater benefit than a placebo.  That's not to say that the placebo effect isn't a powerful one, but it does mean that a lot of people are wasting massive amounts of money, and funding companies who fraudulently seek to profit from their continued suffering.  The warmth generated by the above product will help to enhance the placebo effect of magnet therapy, because the victim believes that he can actually feel it working via the bandage warmth and pressure.  Victims are then likely to become life-long purchasers of these products.

In the meantime, copper magnet bracelets have also become popular.  They are alleged to assist with joint pains and arthritis, because they contain copper.  While copper has been proven to help with these things, it is impossible for enough copper to absorb transdermally from a solid bracelet to make any difference.  For effective ways to help with these chronic pains, read our article, Naturally Eliminating Joint and Arthritis Pain.  Some readers should also read about, Our High-End Colloidal Copper Skin Lotion.  Unfortunately, we cannot "make unapproved claims" about our own lotion in regards to arthritis, damaged tendons, or serious skin diseases, but it is worth doing some research of your own, if you suffer from these things.  Sorry, but telling you more would be competing with Big Pharma, and that's illegal in the U.S..  We could make all the claims we wished to make if we were hurting people with fraudulent claims about magnets, M.M.S., foot detoxification, or Reiki "spiritual energy healing" (witchcraft), because these things ultimately malign alternative medicine for their benefit, and the benefit of their business partners.

Related Articles

Quackery: Foot Cleanses, Detox Foot Pads, and Ionic Foot Baths

Another Fraud Of Alternative Medicine: M.M.S.

The Debate between HealthWyze.org and Jim Humble about whether M.M.S. is a Fraud

Silica Supplements: Just Another Fraud

A Dangerous Pharmaceutical Espoused as 'Alternative Medicine': Dichloroacetic Acid (DCA)

 

 

Comments (3)
  • Josh  - This Whole Article is a Fraud!
    avatar

    You make a lot of "this is a scam because" statements, yet provide no supporting evidence other than your own thoughts.

    Try doing some real research first. Here's a start:

    http://www.virginia.edu/uvatoday/newsRelease.php?id=3573

    A 5-year long study at the University of Virginia - funded by an $875,000 grant from the NCCAM - found that magnets could dilate capillary blood vessels, increasing blood flow. This is consistent with dozens of other studies on blood microcirculation and pressure done in Japan.

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16108042

    Researchers at U.Va. also found that magnets could decrease inflammation. They tested the effects on rats - meaning this is NOT a placebo effect. Particularly when a biological response can be accurately measured.

    Ca2+ (calcium) is an electro-chemical ion. It is used by the body as a messenger, signaling the contraction of smooth muscle - which capillary vessel walls are made of. Ions can be affected chemically (by drugs), as well as by external electrical fields (TENS units) and magnetic fields (static or PEMF).

  • Thomas Corriher (Managing Editor)
    avatar

    I noticed that in the first "study", which by the way, wasn't listed in the regular channels was rather sketchy on the details about how the actual study was conducted, but more importantly, I noticed the following quote.

    Quote:
    "We now hope to implement a series of steps, including private investment partners and eventually a major corporate partner, to realize these very widespread applications that will make a positive difference for human health"


    Ah... this is how the science works. They got the results they needed to get a "corporate partner" and drive "private investment partners" to them.

    I won't even go there on the second study from Japan, but I will comment that one can find even more studies validating blood letting (phlebotomy) than you can magnet therapy. Don't forget that radiation cures cancer too! I really try, but it is so hard to be professional with this level of stupidity.

    The experts in magnetic fields are electronic engineers. Want to guess what I went to college for? Magnetic fields effect neither calcium, nor do they generally effect "ions" (unless you're on a space mission, space cadet). Because of of the laws of (static) electricity, ions are actually pretty rare in our "grounded" world, like the case of ball lightening. Of course, we can throw around fancy-smancy words like "ions" and people are too intimidated to question us, right? You might want to try another site for those tricks.

    Electricity is made magnetically, and the vise versa is possible, but that has nothing to do with minerals like the calcium in our bodies, which by the way isn't ionic.

    How about making a video of a magnet sticking to a piece of chalk (calcium) and sending it our way? We'd be happy to pubish it and offer an apology for this gross travesty of journalism. We'll even clear you to "ionize" that piece of chalk first, if you can find any way at all to do it. I'll be on the edge of my seat waiting for the evidence.

  • Sarah Cain (H.W. Researcher)
    avatar

    Anything that can be effected by magnets can also be magnetized. Personally, I would love to see a calcium magnet. Handling it could be shocking experience, though, with it being ionic and all.

    Think of the applications in the schools... the chalk could stick to the blackboard.


Only members may write comments.